Skip to content

Brought to you by

Dentons logo

Driverless Commute

A digest clocking the most important technical, legal and regulatory developments shaping the path to full autonomy

open menu close menu

Driverless Commute

  • Home
  • About Us
  • News on AVs
  • Global AV Index
  • Global Guide to AVs 2023
    • Executive summary
    • Australia
    • Canada
    • China
    • Germany
    • Hungary
    • Italy
    • Poland
    • South Korea
    • Turkey
    • United Kingdom
    • United States

Talking cars: The FCC holds the key to unlocking the promise of autonomous vehicles

By Eric Tanenblatt, Lauren Wilson, and Todd Daubert
January 28, 2019
  • Autonomous Vehicles
  • Driverless Commute
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn

The dream fueling the development of driverless systems is a world where people and goods are transported quickly and efficiently, and without the accidents, pollution or visual clutter that are inevitable when humans control each vehicle individually. In this imagined new world, each vehicle would be optimized for its intended use, allowing us to reclaim all of the time and money we currently waste sitting in traffic or waiting for goods to arrive. In fact, the technologies needed to support autonomous vehicles are improving so quickly that this dream could soon become a reality, which has awakened regulators and lawmakers to the pressing need to confront the issue of digital roadway management.

One key to facilitating connected transportation and autonomous vehicles is efficient management of the spectrum upon which the vehicles will rely. Regulators around the world will have to adopt, implement and, on an as-needed basis, refine the rules for how this spectrum will be assigned, used and protected from interference.

In the United States, the Federal Communication Commission (FCC), to facilitate vehicle-to-vehicle and vehicle-to-infrastructure communication, in 1999 allocated the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band for transportation communication traffic using dedicated short-range communication (DSRC). Since then, several automakers and a handful of state departments of transportation have outfitted vehicles and infrastructure with DSRC-based technologies. Not surprisingly, technology has improved significantly since then, leading to the development of various alternatives to DSRC, the most notable being cellular vehicle-to- everything (C-V2X) communication, a unified connectivity platform designed to offer vehicles low-latency vehicle-to-vehicle (V2V), vehicle-to-roadside infrastructure (V2I) and vehicle-to-pedestrian (V2P) communication.

C-V2X offers various advantages over DSRC. For example, C-V2X does not require a large-scale deployment of roadside units as it was designed to be compatible with forthcoming 5G mobile technology. Also, unlike DSRC, C-V2X uses two separate transmission modes: one for direct communications between vehicles, vehicles and infrastructure and vehicles and pedestrians and other road users; and the other for network communications. The former ideally would leverage the dedicated 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band, while the latter would leverage traditional mobile service networks to enable vehicles to receive information about road conditions and traffic.

Under current FCC regulations, C-V2X systems cannot use the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band. But the agency is considering amending its rules to allow C-V2X or other technologies to be used as alternatives to DSRC. In coordination with the Departments of Commerce and Transportation, the FCC has launched a three-phase research plan to evaluate options for opening the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band for non-DSRC uses. Throughout the study period, stakeholders and the public will be able to express their opinion as to whether the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band should (1) remain allocated solely for DSRC; (2) be preserved solely for additional automotive technologies like C-V2X; or (3) repurposed, in part or in full, to meet increasing demands for additional unlicensed spectrum unrelated to automotive technologies.

Phase I of the research plan was completed in October 2018, and the FCC concluded that DSRC and non-licensed uses, such as Wi-Fi, are safely able the share the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band—a boon to C-V2X deployment, although its conclusion also opens up the possibility that the band’s repurposing could include non-automotive industries. After reviewing public comments on Phase I, the Commission, again in coordination with the DOT and NTIA, will move onto Phases II and III, described in the public notice as follows:

  • Phase II: Basic field tests with a few vehicles at a DOT facility. The Phase II tests will determine whether the techniques to avoid interference that were evaluated in Phase I’s lab tests are effective in the field.
  • Phase III: Tests in “real-world” scenarios, with many vehicles, more test devices and at a suitable facility.

The timetable for completion of Phases II and III has not yet been announced, but that is not stopping key stakeholders from making their preferences known.

To date, opinions on how the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band rules should be amended have varied significantly. Several automakers, hardware developers and state departments of transportation that are heavily invested in DSRC have, not surprisingly, advocated for maintaining the status quo. They argue that DSRC technology is both immediately available and has been validated as a means of reducing congestion and traffic fatalities. They also point out that a strong commitment to DSRC from the FCC would incentivize near-term investment by companies wary of investing in DSRC technology due to fear of its being rendered “obsolete” by changes to the FCC’s regulations. The Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, for its part, is urging the FCC not to reallocate the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band, in full or part, to non-automotive uses, arguing that such a move could undermine transportation systems.

Not all auto manufacturers are on the same page. A coalition of automakers, device manufacturers and telecom operators that goes by the name “5GAA” vigorously support a fast rollout of C-V2X.  Joining the 5GAA in its call to reallocate the band is Citizens Against Government Waste, a nonprofit, nonpartisan think tank on a mission to reduce government mismanagement. CAGW argues that the current restrictions on the 5.9 GHz wireless spectrum band are anticompetitive in that they stifle the growth and market viability of more effective 5G compatible technology.

Although the positions of the various stakeholders are unlikely to change significantly throughout the next two phases of the research plan, the findings of record may end up supporting one of the above positions.

Importantly, the US is not the only country debating the merits of C-V2X vs. DSRC. The EU and China are both mulling over their automotive communications options. At present, Europe is leaning towards DSRC while China seems to prefer C-V2X. For auto manufacturers, international regulatory disunion is disconcerting. In an industry dependent on international trade, manufacturers desperately want to avoid varying legal requirements and government preferences that could render their vehicle’s technology useless. Once the US concludes its three-phase examination, a domestic spectrum solution will come into focus. While international consensus is far from inevitable, it’s a battle worth fighting as clear decisions in major markets could influence stakeholders’ decisions in other regions. And if regulators remain at odds, the history of wireless mobile services has demonstrated technology’s ability to accommodate conflicting regional preferences.

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via email Share on LinkedIn
Subscribe and stay updated
Receive our latest blog posts by email.
Stay in Touch
5G Technology, C-V2X, Federal Communications Commission
Eric Tanenblatt

About Eric Tanenblatt

Eric Tanenblatt is the Global Chair of Public Policy and Regulation of Dentons, the world's largest law firm. He also leads the firm's US Public Policy Practice, leveraging his three decades of experience at the very highest levels of the federal and state governments.

All posts Full bio

Lauren Wilson

About Lauren Wilson

Lauren Wilson is a member of the Federal Regulatory and Compliance practice, where she focuses on the communications and technology sectors. Lauren uses her experience and knowledge of the US Executive Branch and the consumer watchdog community to provide clients with strategic advocacy and advice on issues such as privacy and data security, universal service, competition, interconnection and public safety.

All posts Full bio

Todd Daubert

About Todd Daubert

Todd Daubert is a partner in Dentons' Washington, DC, office and chair of the Firm's Communications and Technology sectors. Todd has nearly two decades of experience advising companies that develop, integrate and deploy new technologies in transactional, regulatory, litigation and appellate matters.

All posts Full bio

RELATED POSTS

  • Autonomous Vehicles
  • General

This Week in AV News

By Eric Tanenblatt, Peter Stockburger, and Walker Boothe
  • Autonomous Vehicles
  • Driverless Commute

The Driverless Commute in Bloomberg Law: The Decade-Long Self-Driving Honeymoon Is Over. What’s Next?

By Eric Tanenblatt and James Richardson
  • Autonomous Vehicles
  • Driverless Commute

The Driverless Commute, presented by Dentons: A driver’s license for the robot; why partial automation could lead to carnage on our roads; and Waymo’s new big milestone

By Eric Tanenblatt and James Richardson

About Dentons

Redefining possibilities. Together, everywhere. For more information visit dentons.com

Grow, Protect, Operate, Finance. Dentons, the law firm of the future is here. Copyright 2023 Dentons. Dentons is a global legal practice providing client services worldwide through its member firms and affiliates. Please see dentons.com for Legal notices.

Categories

  • Announcements
  • Autonomous Vehicles
  • Driverless Commute
  • General
  • Global Autonomous Vehicles Survey
  • UAVs
Dentons logo in black and white

© 2025 Dentons

  • Legal notices
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms of use
  • Cookies on this site